Categories

Harms of “alternative medicine” summarized

Posted 14 November 2024

Dr. Edzard Ernst, an emeritus professor at the University of Exeter, has described several categories of harm caused by so-called alternative medicine (SCAM).

They include:

  • direct harm by SCAM therapies such as chiropractic spinal manipulation, acupuncture, and herbal medicine
  • harm such as missing a serious diagnosis or giving false positive diagnoses caused by SCAM diagnostic techniques that haven’t been validated
  • harm caused by SCAM practitioners recommending subpar treatments, offering poor advice, diagnosing conditions that don’t exist, or exaggerating the importance of everyday health impairments
  • harm caused by the industry by leading consumers to misspend their money and by endangering species through the exploitation of natural resources
  • harm caused by unreliable research that undermines trust in science
  • harm caused by fallacious notions, such as “nature knows best,” that undermine rational thought

Ernst concluded:

As the benefits of SCAM are often only marginal or entirely absent, even relatively … Read the rest

Dubious mental health practices spotlighted

Posted 28 August 2024

A recording of the livestream Mind the Science: Saving Your Mental Health from the Wellness Industry with Jonathan Stea (62 minutes), part of the Skeptical Inquirer Presents series, is now available on YouTube. Stea discusses:

  • a coffee enema device promoted on Goop for relief from depression, confusion, nervous tension, and more
  • the cornucopia of misinformation in A Mind of Your Own by Kelly Brogan, M.D.
  • unregulated providers of mental health-related services
  • the nine red flags of pseudoscience
  • clearcut pseudoscientific health care practices
  • somewhat plausible health care practices with some features characteristic of pseudoscience
  • harmful impact of pseudoscientific health care practices, why they are seductive, and how to defend against them
  • science literacy and mental health literacy
  • mental health pseudoscience on social media
  • the anti-psychiatry movement
  • misleading marketing of wellness
  • the branding and rebranding of pseudomedicine
  • journals publishing pseudoscientific papers

Stea, a clinical psychologist and adjunct assistant … Read the rest

Righteous Indignation

Posted 15 January 2013

An interesting article in the Skeptical Inquirer, argues that that profound feelings of insult to a deeply held belief ranks among the most powerful and pervasive failures of human reasoning. It notes that “[A]ppeals to righteous indignation or sanctity—which attempt to shield ideas from contemplation, discussion, investigation, or criticism—are common, impede rational discourse, and should be recognized as logical fallacies.” Read the article

… Read the rest