Posted 26 July 2021
Medical Journal Australia – InSight
DOCTORS at a Sydney liver transplant centre have raised concerns about the rising rate of drug-induced liver injury (DILI) cases linked to herbal and dietary supplements, warning these cases are often at the severest end of the spectrum.
Paracetamol remains the drug most commonly linked to DILI, a study of DILI cases at Royal Prince Alfred Hospital’s AW Morrow Gastroenterology and Liver Centre found.
There were 115 paracetamol-related cases and 69 non-paracetamol related cases at the centre over the 12 years to 2020. Of the non-paracetamol DILI cases, antibiotics and antifungals were the most commonly implicated medicines (19 cases). However, the proportion of cases linked with herbal and dietary supplements (15 cases) grew steadily over the period, from 15% to 47% of the non-paracetamol cases.
Cases linked with herbal or dietary supplements had especially poor prognoses, the study found, with 90-day transplant-free survival just 59%, compared with 86% for paracetamol-related DILI.
There were five DILI cases related to anabolic steroids or bodybuilding supplements, four to traditional Chinese medicine, three to weight loss supplements, one to kava, one to cassia cinnamon and one to curcumin. The three weight-loss supplements linked to DILI all contained Garcinia cambogia (also known as Garcinia gummi-gutta).
Writing in the MJA, the authors said their findings reflected the rise in supplement use in Australia over the past two decades, including the purchase of herbal and dietary supplements online, which largely escapes Australian regulatory oversight.
Lead study author, Dr Emily Nash, told InSight+: “With increasing safety concerns regarding DILI associated with specific listed products, it might be timely for a [Therapeutic Goods Administration (TGA)] review of this issue and an advisory to the general public, particularly in those communities where particular agents are used more commonly.”
About half of the patients with supplement-related DILI had non-European backgrounds, the study found.
“It is important to respect culturally diverse communities’ beliefs regarding herbal medicines,” Dr Nash said.
“Where there is evidence of harm, translating that evidence into non-judgmental messages, delivered via culturally appropriate means is important.”
The majority of herbal and dietary supplements sold in Australia are included in the Australian Register of Therapeutic Goods as low risk “listed” medicines (labelled AUST L), as distinct from higher risk “registered” medicines (labelled AUST R). There is no pre-market evaluation of listed medicines.
Dr Ken Harvey, Honorary Adjunct Associate Professor of the Institute for Evidence-Based Healthcare at Bond University, has repeatedly called for regulatory changes to reduce the burden of harms linked with listed medicines.
“A low risk product does not mean there is no risk,” he said. “The TGA should conduct more post-marketing surveillance on listed products, especially Chinese traditional and Ayurveda medicines that have been associated with adverse events, contamination and adulteration, and they should also publicise their findings.”
Dr Harvey also urged the TGA to mandate an educational statement on the pack and promotional material of medicines making traditional claims, to say that the product is based on “traditional beliefs and not modern scientific evidence”.
In the latest MJA study, the biggest increase in DILI associated with herbal or dietary supplements occurred between 2018 and 2020 – after the TGA introduced the Therapeutic Goods (Permissible Indications) Determination in 2018.
“This regulatory change meant sponsors of complementary medicines could no longer make up their own indications but had to choose from a TGA approved list,” Dr Harvey said.
“However, the industry was allowed to create the list. This effectively removed the need for complementary medicines to have a scientific evidence base,” he said.
“Not surprisingly, the number of listed medicines claiming ‘traditional use’ and containing herbal ingredients has increased since then.
“These changes to the regulatory system are likely to be partly responsible for increasing supplement use.”
Nash and colleagues noted their results came from a single centre and might not be generalisable to other settings.
A previous study at the Victorian Liver Transplant Unit identified all cases of acute liver failure in adults hospitalised between January 2002 and December 2017. It found herbal medicines were implicated in only two out of 101 drug-related cases. These were black cohosh herb and kava.
Adjunct Clinical Professor Amanda Nicoll, Director of Gastroenterology at Eastern Health in Melbourne told InSight+: “It’s very hard to regulate complementary medications.
“There’s an incorrect assumption by the community that these agents are safe because they are natural,” she said.
“Because herbal products are known by a number of different names it is difficult to know what is actually in them.”
A TGA spokesperson told InSight+ a number of enhancements had recently been made to the listed medicines compliance framework.
For instance, in December 2019, the TGA began publishing on its website the results of all compliance reviews for listed medicines in a searchable database.
“The TGA takes action to protect consumers,” the spokesperson said. For instance, the TGA recently recalled medicines containing the herb Fallopia multiflora and withdrew the permission for use of the ingredient in listed medicines due to the risk of liver damage.
Regarding body-building supplements, the TGA noted listed medications cannot contain anabolic steroids. The TGA also made a declaration in September 2020 that certain sports supplements are therapeutic goods and not foods, and needed to be regulated as such.
Products available on international websites are not regulated by the TGA, the spokesperson warned:
“Products that are not regulated by the TGA may not meet Australian manufacturing quality standards, and could also contain undisclosed harmful ingredients or toxic contaminants that can pose a serious risk to health.”
7 thoughts on “Drug-related liver injury: call for better regulation of supplements”
- Dr Ken Harvey says:
The TGA spokesperson said:
“The TGA has begun publishing on its website the results of all compliance reviews for listed medicines”. But they don’t say that post-marketing surveillance on around 150 of 10,000 listed products per year, shows that, over the last 5 years, around 75% are found no-compliant, mainly because they lack evidence to support the claims made. Data buried at: https://www.tga.gov.au/annual-performance-statistics-reports
“The TGA takes action to protect consumers”. Yet, the TGA have taken NO action on ineffective complementary medicine weight loss supplements that don’t work and put consumers at unnecessary risk. This includes products containing Garcinia cambogia (implicated in 3 of the above case reports). A recent systematic review and meta-analysis of herbal medicines for weight loss confirms the lack of evidence for this (and other herbal ingredients) for weight loss. See: https://dom-pubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/dom.13973
- Beverley says:
A very simple addition to Mark Arnold’s contribution re natural = safe v unnatural (manufactured) = toxic.
Strychnine is a natural product from Nux Vomica. Digoxin is a natural product from Foxglove plant etc…
- David Henderson says:
Hemlock is a natural substance, which Socrates did not take to improve his health.
- Mark Arnold says:
This report highlights the ubiquitous problem of assessing LFT abnormalities that arise during the course of treatment with various medications in persons with multiple comorbidities, particularly hepatic steatosis and various therapies.
It is in the nature of belief systems that they cannot be overturned by rational argument – that’s why they are beliefs. Some contemporary belief systems attribute moral status to molecules and compounds that reflects the naturalistic fallacy (natural = good as distinct from ‘manufactured’ = unnatural = bad/toxic). This epistemology typically excludes the established science that if a compound has an effect (whether or not that is proven) it can also have off-target effects. As with ‘unnatural’ substances, there are active agents in ‘natural’ substances may have both positive and deleterious effects, the latter directly or indirectly by influencing CYP and drug transporters, potentially affecting the pharmacology of prescribed medications, along with the effect of unnamed substances or adulterants sometimes present in unregulated compounds.
Awareness of a patient’s beliefs will often be a clue as to the reason why they consume non-TGA regulated, eclectic or uncontrolled substances, and a clue to the origin of hepatotoxicty.
- Randal Williams says:
There was certainly a recent case in SA of liver failure requiring transplantation associated with the ingestion of Black Cohosh, heavily promoted for everything from menopausal symptoms to osteoporosis, and to my knowledge nothing was done to remove it from the shelves of pharmacies and “health” food shops, or provide appropriate warnings. Unfortunately for reasons of profit many pharmacists are complicit in stocking and promoting herbal remedies of all types, whether there is evidence of benefit or not, and some can are actually harmful or interact with prescribed medication. .Products that are “natural” are assumed by the public to be good, or at least harmless but of course we know that there are many natural poisons in Nature. TGA seems to have no control over these products, which are often cunningly classified as foods or supplements rather than medications.
- Anonymous says:
55% of the 112 paracetamol related transplants were due to a deliberate single episode overdose, the rest presumably accident
- Anonymous says:
‘Might be timely for the TGA to review’. Really.
This quackery has been going in for decades.
I have witnessed preventable deaths occurring in oncology and haematolgy units due to major drug interactions (with consequential liver failure) between prescribed therapeutic medications and the unreported (deliberately concealed) use of these toxic agents by patients. Lead and arsenic contamination of uncontrolled imported ‘herbal’ rubbish has constantly been reported by laboratories for years also.
Whist the ED vs LD for paracetamol is well known, this article does not comment on the statistics of deliberate vs accidental overdoes with this proprietary drug. An important consideration..
(I have not read the original MJA article however)